Common beliefs about Jesus's birthdate

The common understanding of Jesus's birthday is December 25th. This date is recognized globally and celebrated with pomp and joy as Christmas. The tradition of celebrating Jesus's birthday on this date began in the 4th century. However, the New Testament of the Bible does not provide a specific date for the birth of Jesus, which fuels the ongoing debate about the true date of His birth.

The December 25th date coincided with the pagan festivals celebrating Saturnalia and the Winter Solstice. The Church hoped that selecting this date would encourage the conversion of pagans to Christianity. Nevertheless, the date of December 25th is not based on any biblical or historical evidence that Jesus was born that day.

Another theory posits that early Christians chose December 25th to replace the Roman festival of Saturnalia, a week-long period of lawlessness celebrated between December 17-25. Roman courts were closed during this time, and Roman law dictated that no one could be punished for damaging property or injuring people. The incorporation of Christmas on December 25th was perhaps an attempt to control the unruly celebrations.

Does the Bible confirm the exact date of Jesus’ birth?

The Bible does not specify the exact date of Jesus's birth. Instead, it provides clues that have led to speculation and debate among scholars and religious individuals. In the Gospel of Luke, for instance, the shepherds are said to be "keeping watch over their flocks by night" when they receive the news of Jesus's birth. This detail is significant because shepherds typically watch their flocks during the warmer months, not in the middle of winter.

Luke 1:26 describes Jesus as conceived about six months after John the Baptist was conceived.

However, any attempt to correlate Jesus's birth to his cousin, John the Baptist, must be met with suspicion due to the unknown dates of Zachariah's priestly servitude.

Another clue comes from the Gospel of Matthew, which describes the Wise Men, or Magi, following a star to find the newborn Jesus. Some scholars have suggested that this star was a conjunction of planets, which can be predicted and dated. These planetary conjunctions happened several times in the years around Jesus's birth, but none of them occurred in December.

Though rich in symbolic detail, the Gospel narratives about Jesus’s birth are not precise historical accounts. They were written to convey theological truths, not to provide a biographical timeline. Therefore, while the Bible gives us valuable insights into the circumstances of Jesus's birth, it does not confirm an exact date.

Evidence supporting Jesus's birth in April

Despite the tradition of celebrating Jesus's birthday in December, much evidence supports the theory that Jesus's real birthday is in April. The primary evidence comes from the biblical account itself. As mentioned, the shepherds watched their flocks at Jesus’s birth in the fields. In Israel, this would have been more likely to occur in the spring than in the middle of winter.

Also, the Bible mentions that Mary and Joseph were traveling to Bethlehem to participate in a census. Historically, these censuses were not taken in winter, when temperatures often dropped below freezing and roads were in poor condition. Spring, with its more temperate weather, would have been a more likely time for a census.

Furthermore, early Christians may have initially celebrated Jesus's birth in the spring. The first recorded date of Christmas celebrated on December 25th was in 336, during the time of the first Christian Roman Emperor, Constantine. A few years later, Pope Julius I officially declared that the birth of Jesus would be celebrated on the 25th December. Before this time, however, different Christian groups celebrated Christmas on different dates, including January 6, March 25, and indeed, sometime in April.

The specific date: Could Jesus's birthday be April 17?

Some scholars have proposed a specific date for Jesus's birth: April 17. They base this theory on historical records, astronomical calculations, and the Jewish calendar. According to this theory, Jesus would have been conceived during the Jewish festival of Hanukkah, and born nine months later, in mid-April.

Astronomical calculations support this theory. In the years 6-4 BC, there was a series of three conjunctions between Jupiter, the king planet, and Regulus, the king star. The Wise Men, who were likely skilled astronomers, would have interpreted this rare event as a sign of a royal birth. The final conjunction occurred on April 17, 6 BC, which some believe to be the date of Jesus's birth.

While this theory is intriguing, it is not universally accepted. There is still much debate among scholars about the exact date of Jesus's birth. Still, the evidence for an April birthday is compelling and adds another layer to our understanding of the life of Jesus.

Why does the date of Jesus's birth matter?

You might be asking, "Why does all this matter? Why does it matter when Jesus was born?" To many believers, knowing the actual date of Jesus's birth is not as important as the fact of His birth. His birth signifies the moment when God became man and entered human history. The specific date of that occurrence doesn't change its significance.

However, understanding the historical context of the Bible can enrich our understanding of its stories. Knowing that Jesus was likely born in the spring, not in the depths of winter, can change how we perceive the nativity story. It brings a greater depth of realism to the biblical narrative and can enhance our appreciation of these ancient texts.

In addition, exploring these questions can stimulate a thoughtful conversation about the Bible and its interpretation. It can open up new avenues of understanding and prompt us to question our assumptions about familiar stories. In this way, the question of Jesus's birth date serves as a starting point for deeper exploration and discussion.

Why do some people believe Jesus was born on Apr. 6?

The belief that Jesus was born on April 6 is based on several pieces of evidence, both biblical and historical. As mentioned earlier, the description of shepherds watching their flocks by night suggests a spring birth. Also, the timing of the Roman census would have been more likely in the spring than in the winter.

Another piece of evidence comes from early Christian traditions. Some early Christian groups celebrated Jesus's birth in the spring, and April 6 was one of the dates proposed. Although these early traditions were eventually overshadowed by the December 25th date, they provide evidence of a spring birth.

Finally, modern revelations also support an April 6 birthdate. In the Doctrine and Covenants, a book of modern revelations for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, it is stated that the Church was organized on April 6, "in the one thousand eight hundred and thirtieth year of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ." Some members of the Church interpret this to mean that Jesus was born on April 6.

‍

‍

Why do some religious scholars question the December date?

Many religious scholars question the December date for Jesus's birth for several reasons. First, the Bible does not specify a date for Jesus's birth. The December 25th date was chosen centuries after the events of the New Testament, and for reasons that had more to do with politics and culture than historical accuracy.

Second, the biblical clues about the timing of Jesus's birth suggest a date other than December 25th. The shepherds watched their flocks by night, suggesting a warmer time of year. The Roman census would also have been more likely conducted in a season other than winter.

Finally, many scholars question the December date because it coincides with pagan festivals. They argue that the Church chose December 25th to replace these pagan celebrations with Christian ones, not because it was the actual date of Jesus's birth.

Debunking Myths: Was Jesus born in the Winter or Summer?

Given the evidence, it seems more likely that Jesus was born in the spring rather than the winter. The biblical clues about shepherds and the Roman census suggest a warmer time of year. Historical records and astronomical calculations also support a spring birth.

It's also unlikely that the Roman official, Caesar Augustus, would have issued a decree for a census in December (Luke 2:1).

However, whether Jesus was born in winter, spring, summer, or fall, the important thing is not the date but the event it commemorates. The birth of Jesus marked the beginning of a new era in human history. It represents the moment when God entered into the human experience and forever changed the course of history.

In conclusion, while we may never know the exact date of Jesus's birth, we can be confident that it happened. And that is a cause for celebration, no matter what the calendar says. The mystery of Jesus's real birthday in April deepens our understanding of the Bible and the life of Jesus.

‍