Education

Is It A Sin To Read The Book Of Enoch?

Discover the truth about the Book of Enoch! Uncover what the Bible says about reading it. Don't miss out on this fascinating and controversial discussion.

Last Updated:
December 25, 2023
July 26, 2023
  •  

Understanding the Book of Enoch: An Overview

The Book of Enoch (also known as 1 Enoch) is an ancient Jewish religious work ascribed to Enoch, the great-grandfather of Noah. It's filled with complex narratives, prophecies, and visions that provide profound insights into angelic hierarchies, cosmology, and the spiritual world. Scholars believe that the First Book of Enoch, regarded as 1 Enoch, traditionally dates back to the 2nd century BCE.

The book has been referenced in Jude 1:14-15, “And Enoch also, the seventh from Adam, prophesied of these, saying, Behold, the Lord cometh with ten thousands of his saints, To execute judgment upon all, and to convince all that are ungodly among them of all their ungodly deeds which they have ungodly committed, and of all their hard speeches which ungodly sinners have spoken against him.” This is a direct quote from 1 Enoch 1:9.

Origen, Tertullian, and other early church fathers in the 2nd and 3rd centuries mentioned and quoted the Book of Enoch in the Greek translation of their works. There is good evidence that it influenced their thinking about the Old Testament. But our church fathers ultimately decided to exclude it from canon.

By the 4th century, the Book of Enoch was mostly excluded from Christian biblical canons.

It was only re-discovered in 1773 by the Scottish explorer James Bruce, in Ethiopia, having been preserved only in the sacred Ge'ez language.

The book’s contested status among biblical texts is the primary reason for this confusion. The Book of Enoch isn't included in the canonical Hebrew or Protestant Bible. However, it's considered canonical by the Ethiopian Orthodox Church. This uneven acceptance has led to varied interpretations and perceptions about the book, raising various queries and doubts.

Despite the controversy surrounding its status, the Book of Enoch has undeniably influenced certain elements of Christian theology. The concepts of the Messiah, resurrection, and judgment in the New Testament bear striking resemblances to the narrative in the Book of Enoch. This intriguing correlation adds another layer of complexity to the discussion about its place in Christian theology.

The Controversy: Why was the Book of Enoch removed from the Bible?

"Why was the Book of Enoch removed from the Bible?" is a question that has puzzled many believers. The Book of Enoch was never officially included in the Jewish or Protestant Bibles but was part of some early Christian canons. However, by the fourth century, it was largely excluded due to doubts about its authorship, content, and theological compatibility with other recognized books of the Bible.

The controversy around this book primarily concerns the assertion that it contains 'extra-biblical' revelations. These are concepts and ideas that don't align with the traditional beliefs and doctrines of mainstream Christianity. Some view these revelations as heretical, supporting the argument for their exclusion.

The decision to exclude the Book of Enoch from the Bible was not simple or unanimous. It was the result of multiple councils and theological debates that spanned centuries. Each church and denomination had its criteria for canonization, leading to differing views on the book's validity and relevance.

Is the Book of Enoch in the Catholic Bible?

The Roman Catholic Church, similar to most Protestant churches, does not consider the Book of Enoch as part of its biblical canon. Like its Protestant counterpart, the Catholic Bible includes the books accepted by the Jewish canon, with additional books recognized in the deuterocanonical literature, also known as the Apocrypha. However, the Book of Enoch isn't among them.

The Catholic Church, while acknowledging the historical and theological significance of the Book of Enoch, does not accord it the same authority as the canonical books. This is primarily because the Church follows the Septuagint – the Greek version of the Old Testament, which doesn't include the Book of Enoch.

However, it's important to note that not being in the Catholic Bible doesn't necessarily mean that the Book of Enoch is entirely disregarded or condemned by the Church. Rather, it's viewed as 'pseudepigrapha,’ meaning it's of uncertain authorship or authenticity.

Should Christians read the Book of Enoch?

It's undeniable that the Book of Enoch is an intriguing piece of religious literature, providing unique perspectives on early Jewish thought, angelology, and cosmology.

However, as it is not included in the traditional Biblical canon, some Christians might hesitate to read it, worrying it may lead them astray from orthodox beliefs. On the other hand, others may view it as a valuable resource to gain a broader understanding of biblical times and the evolution of Jewish and Christian theology.

Whether or not you should read the Book of Enoch as a Christian largely depends on your personal faith journey and how you approach religious texts outside the Bible. It's recommended to approach such texts with an open mind, yet grounded in the foundational teachings of the Bible.

What does God say about the Book of Enoch?

"What does God say about the Book of Enoch?" is a tricky question since there is no direct biblical reference or divine commentary on this specific book. The Bible, as we have it today, does not directly address the Book of Enoch.

That said, it's worth noting that the Book of Jude in the New Testament does quote a prophecy from the Book of Enoch. This suggests that the author of Jude considered the Book of Enoch to be authoritative, or at least valuable, in some respect. However, this reference should not be considered a blanket approval of the entire Book of Enoch.

The Bible encourages believers to test everything and fast to what is good. This can be applied when considering the Book of Enoch. It's advisable to approach it with discernment, cross-referencing its content with the teachings and doctrines found in the canonical scriptures.

Is the Book of Enoch inspired by God?

Some believe it to be divinely inspired, given the profound spiritual insights and prophecies it contains. However, others argue that its exclusion from the Bible implies it lacks divine inspiration.

The matter of divine inspiration is complex and often subjective. Most Christian denominations believe that the Holy Spirit inspired the canonical books of the Bible. However, opinions vary when it comes to non-canonical texts like the Book of Enoch.

Ultimately, the perceived inspiration of the Book of Enoch, like any religious text outside the established canon, is largely a matter of personal faith and interpretation. It's always recommended to approach such texts with discernment and a strong grounding in the foundational teachings of the Bible.

Insights from Theologians and Bible Scholars

Theologians and Bible scholars have varying opinions on the Book of Enoch. Some view it as an important historical document that sheds light on early Jewish theology, while others dismiss it as a non-canonical text containing questionable doctrines.

Many scholars appreciate the Book of Enoch for its historical and cultural value. It provides insights into the religious thought and practices of the period it was written. This includes understanding angels, demons, and the end times, which are topics of considerable interest in biblical studies.

However, caution is advised when reading the Book of Enoch. As it is not canonical, its teachings should not be regarded on par with the Bible. Instead, it can be a supplementary resource to deepen understanding of biblical times and concepts.

Is the Book of Enoch considered a Canon of Scripture?

While most Christian and Jewish bodies do not consider the Book of Enoch canonical scripture, it still holds a significant place in religious and historical discussions. Its exclusion from the Bible raises questions about its biblical authority and interpretation challenges. Scholars and theologians have debated its authenticity and debated its authorship. Traditional Christians rejected the book due to its alleged discrepancies with other scriptures and flawed doctrines. However, despite its non-canonical status, the Book of Enoch offers valuable insights into ancient Jewish and early Christian beliefs. Readers can deepen their understanding of biblical themes and historical context by examining this text with wisdom and discernment.

Understanding the Dilemma: Is Reading the Book of Enoch a Sin for Christians?

Exercise caution and approach the Book of Enoch with wisdom and discernment. When reading this ancient text, it is important to understand that most Christian and Jewish bodies do not consider it a canonical scripture. The Bible does not endorse the Book of Enoch but is referenced in Jude 1:14-15. However, its authorship is disputed, and interpretation challenges arise from its content.

However, the Book of Enoch can provide valuable historical and theological insights if approached with discernment and used as a supplementary resource. Always remember, the Bible is the ultimate authority for Christian faith and practice. Any extra-biblical reading should be done with this understanding in mind.

In exploring the Book of Enoch, it is crucial to exercise discernment. Here are three emotional responses that may arise when delving into this text:

  • Intrigue: The Book of Enoch offers a unique perspective on the origin of Nephilim and demons, which can ignite curiosity and fascination.
  • Confusion: Including doctrines that contradict biblical truths can perplex readers and question their understanding of the divine.
  • Enlightenment: Despite its flaws, the Book of Enoch can provide insights into ancient beliefs and the historical context in which it was written.

In conclusion, whether you read the Book of Enoch, do so thoughtfully, prayerfully, and with an open but discerning mind. If you have doubts or questions, it's always wise to consult your pastor, a trusted spiritual mentor, or a Bible scholar.

Frequently asked questions

Why is the Book of Enoch not included in the Bible?

  • The Book of Enoch is not included in the Bible due to its authenticity and doctrinal issues.
  • Traditional Christians believed God did not inspire it and taught contradictory doctrines.
  • Scholars suggest it was written by multiple authors or changed over time.
  • Despite its exclusion, the Book of Enoch holds importance in understanding ancient beliefs and historical context.
  • It provides insights into the beliefs and traditions of early Jewish and Christian communities.

Did Jesus read the Book of Enoch?

  • There is no direct evidence that Jesus quoted from or read the Book of Enoch.
  • However, some believe that Enoch, the figure mentioned in the book, had special knowledge that Jesus may have been aware of.
  • This speculation is based on the idea that Enoch walked with God and had insight into heavenly realms.
  • The Bible does not definitively answer whether Jesus read the Book of Enoch or had knowledge of its contents.

What does the Church say about the Book of Enoch?

  • The Church does not consider the Book of Enoch a part of canonical scripture.
  • It contains doctrines that are contrary to biblical truths.
  • Christians are free to read it but should do so with discernment.
  • Theological implications of the Book of Enoch are debated amongst traditional Christians.
  • It is important to consider the Church's stance and guidance when engaging with this text.

Is there any historical evidence to support the claims made in the Book of Enoch?

  • The Book of Enoch is not considered a part of the biblical canon nor included in many ancient manuscripts.
  • Scholars have raised questions about its authorship and believe it may have been written by multiple authors or altered over time.
  • Historical accuracy is crucial when evaluating the claims made in the Book of Enoch, but there is limited historical evidence to support them.
  • Therefore, when considering the historical accuracy of the Book of Enoch, caution should be exercised.
  • Further research is needed to understand better the origins and accuracy of the Book of Enoch.

References

  • In Matthew 22:29-30, Jesus said, "You are mistaken, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God…they neither marry nor are given in marriage…like the angels…" (see also Mark 12:24-25, Luke 20:34-36).
Leave a comment
Christian Pure Team
Written By:
Christian Pure Team
Find Out More

Back to top

Related Articles

Instagram @type_writer

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.