Calvinism vs. Lutheranism: An In-depth Comparison

Discover the ultimate battle between Calvinism and Lutheranism. Uncover the key differences and unravel the timeless debate that has shaped religious history.

Last Updated:
January 10, 2024
8 Minutes

What is Calvinism?

Calvinism, also known as Reformed theology, emerged during the Protestant Reformation in the 16th century. It was formulated by the influential theologian John Calvin and has since become a significant branch of Protestant Christianity.

At the core of Calvinism is the belief in the sovereignty of God. It teaches that God is the ultimate authority and control in all aspects of life, including salvation. Calvinists emphasize the complete reliance on God's grace for salvation, considering humanity's total depravity and inability to earn salvation through good works.

One of the key tenets of Calvinism is the doctrine of predestination. According to this belief, God predestines certain individuals for salvation, known as unconditional election, and others for damnation. This concept is based on the idea that God's grace is irresistible, meaning elected people cannot resist its saving power.

Another significant element of Calvinism is the doctrine of limited atonement. Calvinists assert that Jesus' sacrifice on the cross was specifically intended for the salvation of the elect and not for every person.

Additionally, Calvinism teaches the perseverance of the saints, which asserts that those truly elected by God will continue in their faith until the end.

What is Lutheranism?

Lutheranism is a Christian denomination that traces its origins to the reform movement led by Martin Luther in the 16th century. Lutheranism strongly emphasizes salvation by faith alone, known as justification by faith. This core belief contrasts the Catholic Church's teaching of salvation through a combination of faith and good works.

Lutheranism teaches that humanity is inherently sinful due to the concept of original sin, inherited from the disobedience of Adam and Eve. According to Lutheranism, salvation is a gift from God, received by faith, not human effort. This understanding of salvation highlights the grace of God and the central role of Jesus Christ's sacrifice on the cross.

Lutheranism also emphasizes the authority of Scripture as the ultimate source of divine truth and guidance for the Christian faith. Lutherans believe that the Bible is the inspired word of God and reject the authority of any other human institution in matters of faith and doctrine.

The Main Difference Between Calvinism and Lutheranism

The main difference between Calvinism and Lutheranism is their contrasting beliefs on atonement, salvation, predestination, sovereignty, and grace.

In terms of atonement, Calvinism teaches the concept of limited atonement, which means that Jesus' sacrifice on the cross was specifically for those predestined for salvation. On the other hand, Lutheranism asserts the idea of universal atonement, believing that Jesus' sacrifice was for the salvation of all humanity.

Regarding salvation, Calvinism holds the doctrine of unconditional election, which means God chooses who will be saved without considering human actions or merits. Lutheranism, however, believes in justification by faith, emphasizing that salvation is received by faith alone, not by any human effort.

On the topic of predestination, Calvinism teaches the doctrine of double predestination, asserting that God predestines some individuals for salvation and others for damnation. Lutheranism rejects this notion and instead emphasizes God's universal will for all people to be saved.

In terms of sovereignty, Calvinism highlights the absolute sovereignty of God over all things, including salvation. Lutheranism also acknowledges the sovereignty of God, but places a greater emphasis on the human responsibility to respond to God's grace.

Lastly, Calvinism emphasizes the concept of irresistible grace, positing that when God calls someone to salvation, they cannot resist. Lutheranism, however, believes in the concept of resistible grace, stating that individuals can resist and reject God's grace.

In sum, while Calvinism and Lutheranism are Protestant traditions, they differ in their beliefs on atonement, salvation, predestination, sovereignty, and grace. These differences highlight the diverse theological frameworks within Christianity.

Similarities between Calvinism and Lutheranism

Calvinism and Lutheranism, two major branches of Protestantism, share several key similarities in their theological beliefs. Both denominations recognize the authority of the Bible as the inspired word of God and uphold the doctrine of the Trinity, affirming the belief in one God existing in three persons – Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Additionally, both Calvinism and Lutheranism acknowledge the existence of heaven and hell, emphasizing the eternal consequences of one's faith.

Another significant similarity between Calvinism and Lutheranism is their understanding of salvation. Both denominations believe in the total depravity of humanity, recognizing that individuals are incapable of saving themselves through their efforts. Instead, they emphasize salvation by grace alone, affirming that individuals can be saved solely through God’s unmerited favor.

Furthermore, both Calvinism and Lutheranism strongly emphasize God's sovereignty. They acknowledge God as the ultimate authority and control over all things, including salvation. This recognition of God's sovereignty is accompanied by the belief in the need for individuals to respond to God's grace and accept salvation through faith.

History of Lutheranism

The history of Lutheranism dates back to the 16th century when Martin Luther, a German theologian, broke away from the Catholic Church. Lutheranism emerged as a protest against what Luther saw as corruption and false teachings within the Catholic Church at the time. Luther's publication of his famous Ninety-Five Theses in 1517 marked the beginning of the Protestant Reformation, a movement that sought to reform the practices and doctrines of the Catholic Church. Lutheranism quickly gained followers, particularly in Germany and Scandinavia, and became one of the major branches of Protestantism. The theological foundations of Lutheranism are based on the doctrine of justification by faith alone and the authority of Scripture. Today, Lutheranism is practiced worldwide, with various lutheran church bodies and denominations that adhere to Luther's teachings and continue to influence Christian faith and practice.

Martin Luther's Break with the Catholic Church

Martin Luther's break with the Catholic Church in the 16th century was a pivotal moment in the history of Christianity. Luther, a German monk and theologian, disagreed with several key teachings and practices of the Catholic Church, leading to his decision to separate from it.

One of Luther's main disagreements was the doctrine of justification by faith alone. He believed that salvation comes through faith in Christ alone, whereas the Catholic Church taught that salvation is achieved through faith and good works. Luther's emphasis on justification by faith alone became a fundamental principle of the Protestant Reformation.

Additionally, Luther challenged the authority of the Pope and the Catholic hierarchy. He believed that the Bible, rather than the Church, should be the ultimate source of religious authority. Luther emphasized the importance of individual interpretation of scripture, encouraging people to read and understand the Bible for themselves.

Luther's break with the Catholic Church escalated with significant events. In 1517, he famously nailed his Ninety-Five Theses to the door of a church in Wittenberg, criticizing the Church's sale of indulgences. This act is considered the catalyst for the Reformation. Luther's subsequent writings and teachings expanded upon his disagreements with Catholic doctrine, gaining him many followers across Europe.

In 1521, Luther was officially excommunicated by the Catholic Church due to his refusal to renounce his beliefs. This marked the final rupture between Luther and the Church, leading to the formation of Lutheranism as a distinct Christian denomination.

Luther's break with the Catholic Church stemmed from his theological disagreements, including his belief in justification by faith alone and his rejection of the Catholic hierarchy's authority. These differences ultimately led to the establishment of Lutheranism as a Protestant alternative to Catholicism.

Doctrine of Justification by Faith Alone

The doctrine of justification by faith alone is a central tenet in Calvinism and Lutheranism. In Calvinism, this doctrine is often called "sola fide," In Lutheranism, it is known as "faith alone."

Calvinism and Lutheranism affirm that salvation is not earned through good works but is received by faith in Jesus Christ. They assert that human beings are inherently sinful and incapable of meriting God's favor through their actions. Therefore, justification, or being made right with God, is solely a result of God's grace and is received through faith alone.

However, there are differences in how these two traditions understand and interpret this doctrine. In Calvinism, there is a strong emphasis on predestination, which holds that God predestines certain individuals for salvation. This belief is often referred to as "unconditional election." Calvinists believe that faith itself is a gift from God and is therefore irresistible.

On the other hand, Lutheranism focuses more on the individual's faith experience and their understanding of God's grace. Lutherans believe that faith is necessary for justification, but they do not hold as strong a view of predestination as Calvinists. Lutherans also emphasize the sacrament of baptism, viewing it as a means of grace and a sign of God's acceptance and forgiveness.

Despite these differences, both Calvinism and Lutheranism affirm the essential role of faith in the doctrine of justification. They both teach that salvation results from God's grace, received through faith in Jesus Christ alone, and not by any merit of our own.

Doctrine of Predestination

The doctrine of predestination is a key theological concept in both Calvinism and Lutheranism. However, there are significant differences in how these two Christian traditions understand and emphasize predestination.

In Calvinism, predestination is a central tenet called "unconditional election." Calvinists believe that before the creation of the world, God predestined certain individuals to be saved or damned. The elect, those chosen by God for salvation, are already predetermined to be saved, and nothing can change their outcome. This belief is based on the concept of God's sovereignty and the idea that salvation is entirely dependent on God's grace.

In contrast, Lutheranism does not place as much emphasis on predestination as Calvinism does. Martin Luther himself did not widely advocate for a strong view of predestination. Lutherans believe in divine election and that God chooses who will be saved, but they do not hold a strict notion of predestination. Instead, Lutheranism focuses more on the individual's experience of faith and justification through God's grace.

Overall, the main difference between Calvinism and Lutheranism concerning the doctrine of predestination is the emphasis placed on it. Calvinism strongly emphasizes predestination, highlighting the notion of the elect being predetermined for salvation, while Lutheranism does not give predestination the same level of importance.

History of Calvinism

Calvinism, also known as Reformed theology, traces back to the 16th century and the influential work of theologian John Calvin. During the Protestant Reformation, Calvin expanded upon the ideas of Martin Luther and developed a comprehensive theological system that became a key defining aspect of Protestantism. Calvinism emphasized the sovereignty of God and the doctrine of predestination, which held that God had chosen certain individuals for salvation before the foundation of the world. This belief in unconditional election raised debates and controversies within the Protestant community, particularly with Lutheranism. However, Calvinism gained significant traction and played a vital role in shaping the theological landscape of Europe and beyond. Today, Calvinism remains one of the major branches of Protestantism, influencing various Reformed churches worldwide.

John Calvin and the Reformation

John Calvin played a pivotal role in the Reformation and profoundly impacted Protestantism. Calvin, a French theologian and pastor, established his headquarters in Geneva, Switzerland, where his influence was immediate and enormous.

Calvin's teachings and writings helped shape the development of Protestantism, particularly the theological framework known as Calvinism. His doctrine emphasized the sovereignty of God, the absolute authority of scripture, and the belief in salvation by faith alone.

Under his leadership, Geneva became a center for the spread of Calvinism throughout Europe. His ideas resonated with many individuals seeking an alternative to the Catholic Church's doctrines and practices.

Calvin's influence reached far and wide, and his theological ideas continue to shape Protestant beliefs and practices today. His emphasis on predestination, the belief that God unconditionally chooses who will be saved, and the concept of irresistible grace set Calvinism apart from other Protestant denominations.

John Calvin's contributions to the Reformation and his enduring influence on Protestantism highlight the lasting impact of his teachings and the significance of his headquarters in Geneva.

Basic Teachings of Calvinism

Calvinism, a theological framework developed by John Calvin in the 16th century, encompasses a set of core beliefs distinct from other Protestant denominations. These teachings, often called the Five Points of Calvinism, outline the fundamental doctrines of Calvinist theology.

Firstly, Calvinism recognizes the concept of total depravity, asserting that as a result of the fall of Adam and Eve, every individual is born completely corrupted by sin and devoid of any inherent goodness or ability to merit salvation.

Secondly, unconditional election denotes that God, in His infinite wisdom and sovereignty, chooses certain individuals for salvation, not based on any foreseen merit or human worth, but solely according to His own will and purposes.

Thirdly, limited atonement suggests that Christ's death on the cross was intended specifically to secure the salvation of the elect and not all of humanity.

Fourthly, irresistible grace elucidates the belief that when God intends to save someone, His grace will irresistibly draw that person to Himself, effectively overcoming their sinful resistance and enabling them to freely accept His offer of salvation.

Lastly, perseverance of the saints emphasizes that those whom God has chosen for salvation will be kept secure in their faith until the end, as God's grace and power is sufficient to preserve them.

Throughout Calvin's teachings, a consistent emphasis is placed on the sovereignty of God and the belief that salvation is a result of His unmerited favor and grace alone, received through faith. These core doctrines continue to shape Calvinist theology and significantly influence Protestantism today.

Source of Authority in Christianity: Scripture or Church Tradition?

The debate between Calvinism and Lutheranism regarding the source of authority in Christianity revolves around whether that authority lies in Scripture or Church tradition. Calvinism asserts that the only religious authority is the Bible, with John Calvin emphasizing the importance of Scripture as the ultimate guide for faith and practice. Calvinists believe the Bible alone should be the source for theological doctrines and religious teachings.

On the other hand, Lutheranism holds that religious authority can be warranted to representatives who faithfully convey biblical truths. While Lutherans also affirm the importance of Scripture, they recognize the role of Church tradition and the teachings of the early Church fathers in interpreting and understanding the Bible. Martin Luther, the founder of Lutheranism, believed in the doctrine of sola scriptura, which acknowledges the importance of Scripture but does not reject the value of Church tradition in shaping the Christian faith.

Calvinism maintains that Scripture is the sole source of religious authority, while Lutheranism allows for including Church tradition in interpreting the Bible. These differing perspectives on the source of authority in Christianity have influenced the theological frameworks and practices of Calvinism and Lutheranism.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between Calvinism and Lutheranism?

The main difference between Calvinism and Lutheranism lies in their beliefs about predestination. Calvinism strongly emphasizes the concept of unconditional election, where God predestines certain individuals to be saved or damned before the creation of the world. On the other hand, Lutheranism does not place as much emphasis on predestination, focusing more on the individual's experience of faith and justification through God's grace.

Are Lutherans Calvinists?

No, Lutherans are not Calvinists. While both denominations are part of the broader Protestant tradition, they hold different theological beliefs. Lutherans follow the teachings of Martin Luther, who was a key figure in the Protestant Reformation, while Calvinists follow the teachings of John Calvin. While there may be some similarities between the two, especially in their Protestant roots, the differences in their beliefs, particularly regarding predestination, set them apart.

What is the role of predestination in Calvinism and Lutheranism?

In Calvinism, predestination is a central doctrine, often called "unconditional election." Calvinists believe that God has already predetermined certain individuals to be saved or damned. The elect, those chosen by God for salvation, cannot alter their outcome. On the other hand, Lutheranism believes in the concept of divine election and that God chooses who will be saved. However, Lutherans do not hold a strict view of predestination and place more emphasis on the individual's experience of faith and justification through God's grace.

Are Puritans Calvinists?

  • Puritans were influenced by Calvinist theology, but not all were strict Calvinists.
  • There were varying views on theological points within the Puritan movement, including predestination and the role of grace.
  • Prominent Puritan ministers engaged in debates and had disagreements regarding theology, including the nature of grace and the extent of predestination.
  • Some Puritans leaned towards an Arminian understanding of predestination, which emphasized the role of human choice in salvation.
  • Debates and disagreements among prominent Puritan ministers further illustrate the diversity of theological perspectives within the Puritan movement.

What do Calvinists think about Lutherans?

  • Calvinists and Lutherans share core beliefs of the Protestant faith.
  • They differ in their views on predestination, with Calvinists believing in unconditional election and Lutherans in single predestination.
  • Both groups contribute to the broader Protestant tradition.
  • The differences stem from variations in theological frameworks and interpretations of Scripture.
  • Despite the disagreements, Calvinists view Lutherans as valuable contributors to the Christian faith.

What religion is Lutheran closest to?

  • Lutheranism is a denomination of Protestantism with several similarities to other Protestant groups.
  • One of its key tenets is the emphasis on scripture alone as the ultimate source of authority in faith and Christian doctrine matters.
  • Lutherans believe in justification by faith alone, rejecting the idea that good works or religious rituals can save an individual.
  • Congregational singing is essential to Lutheran worship services, reflecting the Protestant Reformation's desire for more inclusive worship practices.
  • While distinct in its historical origins and some theological nuances, Lutheranism shares many core beliefs with other Protestant denominations.

Is Reformed and Calvinism the same?

  1. Reformed theology and Calvinism are not universally agreed upon as being the same.
  2. Reformed theology includes various Christian denominations that share similar beliefs, while Calvinism specifically focuses on the teachings of John Calvin.
  3. Reformed theology emphasizes the sovereignty of God, the authority of Scripture, and the need for salvation by grace alone through faith in Jesus Christ.
  4. The central doctrines of Calvinism are known as TULIP and emphasize God's sovereign choice in salvation and the eternal destiny of individuals.
  5. While some theologians may identify as Reformed without fully subscribing to all the tenets of Calvinism, understanding the theological nuances and historical context can clarify their relationship.

What are the main differences in the views of atonement between Calvinism and Lutheranism?

  • Calvinism views the atonement as limited to the elect, emphasizing God's sovereignty and predestination.
  • Lutheranism believes that Christ's sacrifice was enough for all and can be received by anyone with faith.
  • Both perspectives acknowledge the importance of Christ's sacrifice, but differ in their understanding of its scope and application.
  • Calvinism emphasizes the need for God's grace to be accepted, while Lutheranism emphasizes the role of faith.
  • The main difference is in understanding the efficacy of Christ's sacrifice and its application.

How do Calvinism and Lutheranism differ in understanding God's sovereignty?

  • Calvinism and Lutheranism both view God's sovereignty as immense and powerful.
  • Calvinism sees salvation as predetermined, while Lutheranism believes that anyone can be saved through faith.
  • Both denominations value the authority of the Bible, salvation through God's grace, and the belief in the Trinity.
  • Calvinism emphasizes God's control, while Lutheranism focuses on justification through faith alone.
  • Despite their differences, both Calvinism and Lutheranism recognize human sinfulness.

What is the role of human free will in the context of salvation in Calvinism and Lutheranism?

  • Calvinism and Lutheranism have different views on the role of human free will in salvation.
  • Calvinism emphasizes God's sovereignty, believing God’s choice completely determines salvation.
  • Lutheranism emphasizes faith in Christ's sacrifice, teaching that anyone can be saved by having faith in Him.
  • Calvinism and Lutheranism recognize the importance of faith in experiencing God's grace and salvation.
  • Faith plays a crucial role in one's journey to salvation.

Do Calvinism and Lutheranism have different perspectives on the concept of grace?

  • Calvinism and Lutheranism both agree on the importance of grace in salvation.
  • In Calvinism, salvation is seen as a result of God's sovereign choice.
  • Lutheranism emphasizes salvation through faith alone.
  • Grace reminds us of God's unconditional love and forgiveness, offering hope and redemption to all.
  • Faith in God is essential for salvation according to both denominations.

How do Calvinists and Lutherans interpret the Bible differently about their theological beliefs?

  • Calvinists and Lutherans interpret the Bible differently according to their theological beliefs, known as comparative hermeneutics.
  • Calvinists emphasize God's sovereignty and predestination, while Lutherans focus on justification through faith.
  • These different approaches shape how they understand and apply biblical teachings.
  • Understanding both perspectives can help us better understand God's Word and grow our faith.
  • It is important to study and appreciate the contrasting perspectives of Calvinists and Lutherans.

Leave a comment
Christian Pure Team
Written By:
Christian Pure Team
Find Out More

Back to top

Related Articles

Instagram @type_writer

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.